‘The Darkest Lie’ Gena Showalter


Forced to his knees in agony whenever he speaks the truth, Gideon can recognize any lie―until he captures Scarlet, a demon-possessed immortal who claims to be his long-lost wife. He doesn’t remember the beautiful female, much less wedding―or bedding―her. But he wants to…almost as much as he wants her.

But Scarlet is keeper of Nightmares, too dangerous to roam free. A future with her might mean ultimate ruin. Especially as Gideon’s enemies draw closer―and the truth threatens to destroy all he’s come to love….


Okay, so anyone familiar with the Lords of the Underworld series will know that sweet, darling Gideon (hm, wonder who my favourite character is!?) is keeper of Lies and, as a result, can’t utter a single truth without suffering intense, debilitating pain…so Gideon communicates in a rather interesting way. Picture this; you meet the man (or woman) of your dreams, perhaps on the daily commute into work, and they flash you a smile that promises sin and seduction. They lean forward and whisper in your ear, their voice nothing more than a husky murmur…

“You’re so ugly.”

Oooo. Awkward…not to mention rude and hurtful! You’d probably give them a slap, right? Now do you understand poor Gideon’s problem? Everything he says is the opposite of what he means and I did seriously consider writing this review in Gideon speech but figured it’d be way too confusing. But enough about Gideon, let’s talk about his book, a book I was eagerly powering through the series to read!

The Darkest Lie has it all; humour, heartache, romance, action, kinkiness…and it’s all rolled up into one tidy package (pfft, package! C’mon, Jazz, be mature about this!) comprised of fantastic world building and equally fantastic writing. The LotU series is set in universe that blends our reality with the conjurings of Gena Showalter’s imagination and the result is a world in which readers can quite easily lose themselves for hours on end. Each of Gena’s characters are as unique as they are believable and I’m not sure if this is fair on the reader’s part because I have genuinely been looking into a weekend break in Budapest and my heart breaks to know I won’t be able to hang out with the Lords!

As for Gideon and Scarlet’s story, I think it’s one the best in the series yet. It’s not just your average run-of-the-mill romance. It runs deeper than that and their relationship is layered with complexity, which makes for an interesting, unexpected twist around half way through. Gideon is the man we all want (okay, maybe generalising there); he’s a little rough around the edges, he’s a bit of a bad boy…and yet he’s kind, sweet and gentle, even if he does struggle with the sweet nothings he whispers in Scarlet’s ear (I’m pretty sure he says at one point “I don’t want you, devil.”, although admittedly it is go-weak-at-the-knees sweet when you’ve translated it). Scarlet is one hell of a bad ass and she’s the woman I think I’ve always tried to be; a tough, take-no-shit exterior but with a squidgy, marshmallow, please-hold-me center (I am purely the latter).

I’ve mentioned this in a previous LotU review, but let’s talk about Cronus for a moment! Am I the only person who thinks he isn’t actually all that bad? Sure, he does have his faults (what he did to Aeron in the first two or three books wasn’t cool, I get that and how he treated Scarlet in Tartarus wasn’t all that nice either) but he’s making amends I like to think. He’s just a regular guy trying to do his best in this cruel, cruel world we live in. I kinda feel he tries to exude this cold-hearted, almighty persona but I think he’s a bit of a softie. He dishes out threats like I dish out baked beans on the breakfast shift at work, but he always, always relents. He’s like “Awww you kids, all loved up. Sure, don’t worry about the threats of eternal damnation and death! You go have fun, ‘k?”

Anyway, the votes are in and…

Rating: 5 out of 5 (in Gideon speak, I hated this book!)

Song: Fleetwood Mac’s Little Lies (I was brushing my teeth this morning and thinking of appropriate songs and when I thought of this, I spat my toothpaste out in excitement (in the sink, whoah, brackets within brackets))


This book is available on Amazon in both e-reader and paperback format.


14 thoughts on “‘The Darkest Lie’ Gena Showalter

  1. OK, first of all… going by your review, that song choice suits perfectly!
    Second… your review entirely makes me want to read this series! 😀 And Gideon does have the most unbelievable dilemma… Kepper of Lies… well, sht! That is one of the most interesting conflicts I’ve heard of….
    Brilliant review, totally entertaining and really… you make me want to try this series out! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Haha thank you! I do love a bit of Fleetwood Mac 😀
      I know this probably isn’t your kinda genre, but it is a fantastic series! Minus the romance and…ahem, the steamy scenes…it’s got some fantastic world building and a whole host of unique characters! You should totally read it 😀 It’d be nice to have a friend who’s a romance junkie like me 😛

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Well… this might be your chance to convert me… no truly, I used to read quite a bit of romance and it all just ended up the same, you know? I think I even wrote a blog post about it years ago saying how the males are always businessmen/machos/bikers/mafia and women spineless and moany and there’s always a BIG misunderstanding… like- the man is seen with another woman and it turns out it was his sister and there’s a big blow up and he will have to sing serenades and beg on his knees… jaysus… 😀 but anyway, I know there’s good romance out there as well, I’ve read some good ones.. so I shall defo try it 🙂 You know what you’re talking about and I trust your word 😉 ❤

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Oh my god, that is actually a dictionary definition of most romance! You’re right…they are ALWAYS businessmen or bikers and they’re always hard headed and annoyingly stubborn, never actually realizing they love the woman until she leaves! 😛
        If you decide to embark upon this series, let me know 😀 We can swoon over fictional men together!

        Liked by 1 person

    1. I know, right? Can you imagine how frustrating it would be? 😛 I don’t know, going into a shop and saying “I don’t want to show me where the bread is” but the assistant, naturally, not understanding what it is you actually meant 😛 It’s a fantastic series, but I appreciate it’s not for everyone. I’m pleased you enjoyed my review, though 😀

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s